Enter a value to see the conversion result
Cumulative Net Cost: Renting vs Buying
How the rent vs buy comparison works
The honest comparison is net cost: everything you pay out, minus the wealth you end up with. Renting means paying rent every month while your down payment stays invested. Buying means paying the mortgage, tax, insurance and maintenance — and ending up owning a home, minus the mortgage balance and selling costs.
Five things most comparisons miss
First, the opportunity cost of the down payment: money not spent on a house can be invested instead. Second, selling costs of about 6% when you move. Third, maintenance at roughly 1% of the home's value a year. Fourth, rent growth — rent rarely stays flat. Fifth, home appreciation, which works in the buyer's favour. Leave any of these out and the answer is wrong.
Worked example
With the defaults — $2,000 rent, a $400,000 home, $80,000 down, a 6.5% mortgage over 30 years, staying 7 years — renting costs $130,590 net versus $166,021 for buying. Renting wins by $35,431, because $2,000 rent is low relative to a $400,000 price.
The price-to-rent rule of thumb
Multiply annual rent by 15. If the result is below the home price, renting usually wins; if it is above, buying usually wins. Here $2,000 × 12 × 15 = $360,000, below $400,000 — consistent with the model.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many years until buying beats renting?
Typically 5 to 7 years, but it depends on the price-to-rent ratio. In the default example it takes 16 years, because the rent is low relative to the home price.
What is the 5% rule?
The unrecoverable cost of owning is roughly 5% of a home's value a year — about 1% property tax, 1% maintenance and 3% cost of capital. If annual rent is below that figure, renting usually wins.
Does a bigger down payment change the answer?
Yes. A bigger down payment means less interest and no PMI, but more cash tied up instead of invested.
What if home prices fall?
The calculator assumes steady appreciation. Flat or falling prices push the breakeven year much later.
Are closing and selling costs really that big?
Buying costs about 2% ($8,000 here) and selling about 6% (about $29,500 on the 7-year value). They punish short stays.
Should I include investment returns?
Yes. Money not spent on a down payment can grow; at 7% the $88,000 of down payment plus closing costs becomes $141,309 in 7 years.